
When I represented the buyers of 2566 Cayenne Lane, a waterfront estate in Shalimar, the home was originally listed at $2.65 million. The seller had paid $2.2 million in 2024. We closed at $2,178,645, more than $470,000 below the original asking price and about $21,000 below what the seller had paid. That sounds like a win right? Let me continue….
If you are familiar with me, you know that I list properties for 1% and in turn, I typically only work with sellers. He had found me on another listing that was half as much, and decided against that one and we started looking at lots of houses together. It was fun to go inside these stunning waterfront properties and I learned more than my fair share about boat lifts docks and the emotions that can run high in high stakes transactions.
I’d never handled a deal this big, on the buyers side, and when my buyers started getting cold feet, I felt it too. With so many houses available that could potentially work, it is easy to understand why they were hesitant. I had plenty of anxiety about the deal falling apart because there was so much money on the line- not the commission but the money my buyers were going to spend. Picturing them closing on a house they were already having doubts about was keeping me up at night.
Everyone thinks that real estate agent care more about the commission than how the buyer feels at the end of the day, but that is 100% not how I operate, and I think most agents feel the way I do too. Buying a home is one of the biggest financial decisions a person makes. When my buyers started having second thoughts, I wanted them to feel comfortable saying so, even if it meant the deal fell apart. The thought of them waking up a month later wishing they’d walked away was what really kept me up. I insisted on inspecting everything. Pool, stucco, dock, house, roof, all major systems.
I negotiated for the home to come fully furnished including the art. The other side countered to exclude the artwork and we agreed and signed. Everything seemed clear enough, unfortunately along the way a text message from the agent saying whatever is still left in there is yours left the buyers with the impression that everything would stay. This is where the job really actually becomes hard because in real estate a conversation is not enforceable even if its a text. The seller’s agent is not the seller, and if they actually did take every piece of art they were entitled to do just that. I had to remind my buyers hey, you were okay with them taking the art, remember, we signed their counter, but bad blood was created with this vague promise via text from the agent.
This is why it’s so important to get an exclusion list with pics if there is ever any questions. I had asked for that repeatedly from the other side but never got it. Thankfully the art that they wanted was left and all was well in the world but that impression caused so much stress.
People hear “buyer’s market” and think the hard part is over. More choices can give you room to negotiate. You still have to figure out what the house is worth to you, what it’ll cost to own, and which questions you need answered before you’re comfortable closing. At Cayenne Lane, we had tough conversations about price and spent real time working through due diligence. Even though we negotiated hard and got if for almost half a million dollars off asking that celebration was short lived. This was a big deal for any buyer, and anxiety was just high and carried through all the way until we closed.
Sometimes the hardest conversation comes after you’ve negotiated a good price. You’ve spent time on inspections and paperwork. You can already picture yourself there. Then something comes up, and you have to ask yourself whether you’d still make the same offer knowing what you know now. I want my buyers to feel comfortable telling me the answer, even late in the process.
I’m proud of the price we negotiated on Cayenne Lane. I’m also glad we had the uncomfortable conversations along the way. When you’re buying a home, you deserve an agent you can tell, plainly, “I’m having second thoughts.”
If you’re looking at a home on the Gulf Coast and wondering how much room you really have to negotiate, send me the address. I’ll help you look at the price, the property, and the questions worth answering before you make an offer.